Florida Sellers Slash Prices As Buyers Bypass The State Entirely — View It As Overpriced And Undervalued With Extreme Insurance Rates

Florida’s real estate market is experiencing a surge in inventory levels, prompting sellers across the state to aggressively cut prices. 

A recent report from Redfin highlights a marked increase in properties for sale, particularly along the Gulf Coast, with some areas seeing inventory spikes of up to 50% compared to last year.

The once-trendy North Port-Sarasota area is now witnessing a 48% jump in homes on the market, signaling a cooling phase for what was one of the hottest housing markets in the nation. Even upscale locales like West Palm Beach are not immune, with inventory rising by 20%.

This uptick in availability is causing a seismic shift in pricing strategies. Data reveals that cities like Tampa, Cape Coral, Orlando and Jacksonville are seeing an unprecedented number of sellers slashing their list prices in a bid to attract buyers in an increasingly bloated market.

Don’t Miss:

Eric Auciello, Redfin’s sales manager, expressed concern over the market’s volatility. 

“The North Port metro was a magnet for competitive housing due to its affordability and shortage of homes,” he said. “Today, those dynamics have flipped, leaving the market oversaturated and overvalued.”

The change is so stark that many potential buyers are bypassing Florida, opting instead for states like North Carolina or Tennessee where their money stretches further. The allure of Florida’s real estate, once irresistible to out-of-town buyers, is waning. 

“Out-of-town homebuyers no longer see Florida as a place to get amazing value,” Auciello said.

Start generating passive income through real estate

Check out these featured investments from Benzinga’s Real Estate Offerings Screener.


Redfin also points to Florida’s ongoing insurance crisis as a major factor dampening buyer enthusiasm. Affordable insurance enjoyed by previous homeowners often isn’t available for new buyers, leaving them with significantly higher premiums. 

Auciello’s personal experience exemplifies this challenge, with his insurance costs doubling from $8,000 to $14,000 annually. This “hefty insurance bill,” as he described it, can be a significant hurdle for waterfront property buyers, who may already face tighter budgets.

Suze Orman, a popular financial guru, recently spoke about how she opted to forego coverage because of exorbitant quotes, like her $28,000 annual insurance quote for an oceanside condo in Florida. The requirement for insurance to secure mortgages is causing many to rethink their investment in Florida real estate, opting instead for states with more favorable economic conditions.

A report from online insurance agency Insurify projects a 7% increase in premiums for 2024, pushing the average annual cost to around $11,759. This increase in insurance costs presents a new factor for both buyers and sellers to consider. While rising inventory may lead to some sellers adjusting their pricing strategies, the long-term impact on market dynamics remains to be seen.

Read Next: